This Show Was Religious?!: Online Reactions to Religion in Lost and Battlestar Galactica Finales

Charlotte Howell

Abstract


As the American populace is increasingly identifying as non-religious, religious representation is surprisingly also increasing on television, leading many to discuss the limits and boundaries of acceptable representations of religion through the cultural forum of television. The series finales of Lost and Battlestar Galactica serve as a particular pair of case studies I place in discussion with each other about religious-representational and generic concerns. Online reactions in discussion forums or comment sections to the religious elements in these finales generally occur in one of two ways: negative reactions that set the religious endings in opposition to the genre expectations viewers had for the shows or generally positive reactions that focus on the religious themes as successful affective tools that provided adequate or at least justified narrative closure. In both discursive strains, the tone was overwhelmingly respectful and occasionally aware that those entering into the discussions were engaging in larger cultural debates, providing one site of exploring the changing role of religion in popular television through a study of expectations of science fiction narratives and their conclusions.


Keywords


Science Fiction; Television; Fan Cultures

Full Text:

PDF

References


AaroniusLives. 2009, April 13. 4-20: ‘Daybreak Part 2’ 2009.03.20 –

TWoP forums. [Msg 1380]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

AaroniusLives. 2010, May 26. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1394]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

AlohaGirl. 2010, May 24. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 883]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

AlohaGirl. 2010, May 26. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 899] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Belili. 2011, Oct. 16. 4-20: ‘Daybreak Part 2’ 2009.03.20 – TWoP forums.

[Msg 1551]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Bobkowski, P. S. and. Pearce, L. D. December 2011. “Baring Their Souls in Online

Profiles or Not? Religious Self-Disclosure in Social Media.” In Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 50, no. 4: 744–762.

Clark, L.S. 2002. U.S. adolescent religious identity, the media, and

the 'funky' side of religion. Journal of Communication 52 (4), 794-811.

Clark, L.S. 2009. You Lost Me: Mystery, Fandom, and Religion in ABC’s Lost.

In Diane Winston (ed.), Small Screen, Big Picture (p. 318-341). Waco: Baylor University Press.

Ddt73. 2010, Oct. 19. TV watchtower: Is religion killing good sci-fi shows?

[Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Eberl, J. T., & Vines, J. A. 2007. “I Am an Instrument of God“: Religious Belief,

Atheism, and Meaning. In J. T. Eberl (ed.), Battlestar Galactica and Philosophy (pp. 155–168). London: Blackwell Publishing Ltd.

Emmett. 2010, May 24. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1168]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

FAQ. [n.d.]. Battlestar Forum. Available at:

[Accessed 12 February

.

Fish, S. 2005, Jan. 7. One university under god? The Chronicle of Higher

Education. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Garyc. 2010, June 10. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1776]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Googuse. 2010, May 24. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1130]. Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Hartwell, D. G. 1996. Age of Wonders. New York: Tor Books.

Hellkiller1234. 2010, March 26. Perhaps God was not omnipotent, after all –

Battlestar Forum. [Web forum comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Hills, M. 2000. Media fandom, neoreligiosity, and cult(ural) studies.

Velvet Light Trap: A Critical Journal of Film & Television, 46, 73-84.

Hinman, M. 2010, Oct. 20. So tell us honestly, is there too much religion in

sci-fi? [Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Jenkins, H. 2006. Convergence Culture. New York: NYU Press.

Johnson, C. 2005. Telefantasy. London: BFI.

Johnson, D. 2007. “Fan-tagonism: Factions, Institutions, and Constructive

Hegemonies of Fandom.” In Fandom, Jonathan Gray, Cornel Sandvoss, and C. Lee Harrington, eds. New York: NYU Press, 285-300.

Kienzl, L. 2014. “You’re My True Vessel”: Knowledge and Digital Fan Culture

Discussed on the Basis of Mediumship and Possession in Supernatural’s Narrative and Fandom. The Journal of Religion, Media and Digital Culture, 3(1), pp. 155–180. [online] Available at:

Klassen, C. 2008. Research note: Rejecting monotheism? Polytheism,

pluralism, and Battlestar Galactica. Journal of Contemporary Religion 23 (3), 355-362.

Kung, M, & Kurutz, S. 2010, Jan. 5. “Lost” last supper promo pic:

Clues buried within? The Wall Street Journal. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

The last supper – Battlestar wiki. (n.d.). Available at:

[Accessed 12 February 2015].

Leahbethm. 2010, June 2. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1718] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Lindelof, D. & Cuse, C. (Writers), & Bender, J. (Director). 2011. The end.

In Abrams, J.J. (Producer), Lost. Los Angeles, CA: ABC Studios.

Mhinman. 2010, Oct. 19. TV watchtower: Is religion killing good sci-fi shows?

[Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

MisterE. 2010, June 18. Creation of the sideways universe/’afterlife’- Lostpedia

forum. [Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Mittell, J. 2004. Genre and television: from cop shows to cartoons in American culture

New York: Routledge.

Moore, R. D. (Writer), & Rymer, M. (Director). 2009. Daybreak, Pt. 2

[Television series episode]. In Moore, Ronald D. & Eick David (Producers), Battlestar Galactica. Los Angeles, CA: Universal Studios.

Neale, S. 2000. Genre and Hollywood. London: Routledge.

Newcomb, H. 1990. Religion on television. In John P. Ferre (ed.),

Channels of belief: Religion and American commercial television. Ames, IA:

Iowa State University Press.

Newcomb, H. & Hirsch, P. M. 2000. Television as a cultural forum.

In Horace Newcomb (ed.), Television: The critical view. New York: Oxford University Press.

Ontheedge22. 2010, May 30. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 –

TWoP forums. [Msg 1627] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Pegannc. 2009, April 8. 4-20: ‘Daybreak Part 2’ 2009.03.20 – TWoP forums.

[Msg 1334] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Pew Forum. ‘No Religion’ on the Rise: 19.6% Have No Religious Affiliation - Pew

Forum on Religion & Public Life. 2012, October 9. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Snowkestrel. 2010, Oct. 20. So tell us honestly, is there too much religion in

sci-fi? [Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Sobchack, V. 1987. Screening Space. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.

Stillshimpy. 2011, Feb. 18. 4-20: ‘Daybreak Part 2’ 2009.03.20 –

TWoP forums. [Msg 1491] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].

Tcurran. 2010, Oct. 19. TV watchtower: Is religion killing good sci-fi shows?

[Web blog comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Thevarrior. 2010, April 21. Perhaps God was not omnipotent, after all –

Battlestar forum. [Web forum comment]. Available at: [Accessed 12 February 2015].

Vogt, T. 2010, Oct 19. TV watchtower: Is religion killing good sci-fi

shows? [Blog article]. Available at:

[Accessed 12 February 2015].

Wondra. 2010, May 25. 6-17: ‘The End’ 2010.05.23 - TWoP forums.

[Msg 1299] Available at: [Accessed 13 October 2011].


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.