Varieties of an Atheist Public in a Digital Age: The Politics of Recognition and the Recognition of Politics

Jack C. Laughlin

Abstract


With the rise of atheism as a cause célèbre in the last decade or more, media and others have offered many interpretations for the apparent growth of nonbelief, ranging from the apocalyptic to the utopian. Many cite the Internet as a major contributing factor to this growth; undoubtedly new media have provided atheism with greater visibility. In this article it is argued that atheism as an Internet phenomenon ought to be understood less as the manifestation of a social fact and more as the discursive constitution of one or more publics in Michael Warner’s sense of the term. To this end, the article draws attention to a body of data that has received limited attention in scholarship to date, namely the blogs of some notable atheists. These are limited to blogs originating in the United States, and especially those by authors who identify as ‘progressive’. Thus, the conclusions drawn are not imagined to apply outside that context, nor are the sources employed considered to be representative of American atheism. But these limitations present no bar to the analysis of the particular discursive practices of the authors in question. Following Warner, virtual atheism as a public or publics has little capacity for agency: even if its growth as a social fact is true, and even as it develops agendas for social change, it is neither discursively or substantively robust enough to challenge any aspect of the contemporary neo-liberal order.


Keywords


Atheism, Internet, Publics, Counterpublics

Full Text:

PDF

References


Advisory Board to the Secular Student Alliance, n.d. Available at [Accessed 15 Apr 2015]

“Ahlquist v. Cranston,” n.d. Wikipedia [online] Available at [Accessed 16 Dec 2014]

Anspach, W., Coe, K. and Thurlow, C., 2007. The Other Closet?: Atheists, homosexuals and the lateral appropriation of discursive capital. Critical Discourse Studies, 4(1), pp. 95–119.

“Ban Lifted: American Atheists to Speak, Table at 2015 CPAC,” 2015. Available at < http://news.atheists.org/2015/02/26/ban-lifted-american-atheists-to-speak-table-at-2015-cpac/> [Accessed 15 June 2015]

Bell, R., 2014. About. Available at http://www.patheos.com/ [Accessed 31 Dec 2014]

Carrier, R., 2014. Chris Hall on the Changing Face of New Atheism. Richard Carrier Blogs, [online] Available at < http://freethoughtblogs.com/carrier/archives/5660> [Accessed 18 June 2014]

Christina, G., 2009. The Top One Reason Religion Is Harmful. Alternet, [online] Available at [Accessed 14 Dec 2011]

Christina, G., 2011. Listening to the Hair Dryer: Why Nice Religion is Still Problematic, Analogy #37,476. Greta Christina’s Blog, [online] Available at < http://freethoughtblogs.com/greta/2011/10/13/listening-to-the-hair-dryer/> [Accessed 13 Oct 2011]

Christina, G., 2012. Major Threat to Religion? Clergy People Coming Out as Atheists. Alternet, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

Christina, G., 2013. The Tragic Assassination of One of the World's Most Prominent Atheists. Alternet, [online] Available at [Accessed 15 Dec 2014]

Christina, G., 2014a. Coming Out Atheist: How to Do It, How to Help Each Other, and Why. Dirty Heathen Publishing. Kindle Edition.

Christina, G., 2014b. Major Threat to Religion? Clergy People Coming Out as Atheists. Alternet, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

Cimino, R. and Smith, C., 2007. Secular Humanism and Atheism beyond Progressive Secularism. Sociology of Religion, 68(4), pp. 407-424.

Cimino, R. and Smith, C., 2011. The New Atheism and the Formation of the Imagined Secularist Community. Journal of Media and Religion, 10(4), pp. 24-38.

Cimino, R. and Smith, C., 2014. Atheist Awakening: Secular Activism and Community in America. Oxford University Press. Kindle Edition.

The Clergy Project, n.d. [online] Available at [Accessed 1 Dec 2014]

“David Silverman,” n. d. Wikipedia, [online] Available at [Accessed 15 June 2015]

Dawkins, R., 2006. The God Delusion. New York: Houghton Mifflin Company.

Dennett, DC and LaScola, L., 2010. Preachers Who Are Not Believers. Evolutionary Psychology 8(1), pp. 122-150.

Dennett, DC and LaScola, L., 2013. Caught in the Pulpit: Leaving Belief Behind. Congruity. Kindle Edition.

Eberhard, J.T., n.d. About. What Would JT Do? [online] Available at [Accessed 8 Feb 2015]

Eberhard, J.T., 2012. The End of Apathy. What Would JT Do? [online] Available at [Accessed 10 Jan 2012]

Former Pastor Decides To Spend A Year Without God, 2014. NPR, [online] Available at [Accessed 31 Dec 2014]

Freedman, S.G., 2013. Minister Admits Overstating Her Credentials. New York Times, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

Hammer, J.H., Cragun, R.T., Hwang, K. and Smith, J.M., 2012. Forms, Frequency, and Correlates of Perceived Anti-Atheist Discrimination. Secularism and Nonreligion, 1, pp. 43-67, DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.5334/snr.ad

Hall, C., 2014. Forget Christopher Hitchens: Atheism in America is undergoing a radical change. Salon, [online] Available at [Accessed 5 June 2014]

Hoelscher, D., 2012. Atheism and the Class Problem. Counterpunch, [online] Available at < http://www.counterpunch.org/2012/11/07/atheism-and-the-class-problem/> [Accessed 26 Jan 2015]

Hoelscher, D., 2014. A Life of Class Consciousness. In: Brewster, M.E., ed. Atheists in America. Columbia University Press.

Hutchinson, S., 2011. Moral Combat: Black Atheists, Gender Politics, and the Values Wars. Infidel Books. Kindle Edition.

Jacobs, T., 2014. Atheists Seen as a Threat to Moral Values. Pacific Standard, [online] Available at [Accessed 14 Dec 2014]

“Jerry DeWitt,” n.d. Wikipedia, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

“Jessica Ahlquist,” n.d. Wikipedia, [online] Available at [Accessed 16 Dec 2014]

Kettell, S., 2014. Divided We Stand: The Politics of the Atheist Movement in the United States. Journal of Contemporary Religion, 29(3), pp. 377-391. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13537903.2014.945722.

Kurtz, P., 2000. The Need to Come out of the Closet. Free Inquiry, 20(3), pp. 5-6.

Mehta, H., n.d. Media. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 26 Jan 2015]

Mehta, H., 2009. Would You Be an Atheist Without the Internet? Available at [Accessed 26 Jan 2015]

Mehta, H., 2011a. New Research Says Anti-Atheist Prejudice Stems from Distrust. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 16 Nov 2011]

Mehta, H., 2011b. Lessons Learned from the Gelato Mio Sign. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 21 Nov 2011]

Mehta, H., 2012a. New Report: ‘A Third of Adults Under 30 Have No Religious Affiliation’. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 9 Oct 2012]

Mehta, H., 2012b. Why Politicians Should Pay Attention to the Non-Religious. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 13 Oct 2012]

Mehta, H., 2012c. A Fundraiser for Jessica Ahlquist. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 13 Jan 2012]

Mehta, H., 2014a. To the Pastor Giving Atheism a Shot for a Year: You’re Doing It Wrong. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 27 Dec 2014]

Mehta, H., 2014b. Remember the Pastor Trying Out Atheism for a Year? He Just Got Fired by His Christian Employers. Let’s Help Him Out. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 27 Dec 2014]

Mehta, H., 2014c. A Year After Giving Atheism a Try, Former Pastor Ryan Bell Admits: “I Don’t Think That God Exists.” Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 27 Dec 2014]

Mehta, H., 2014d. How Christians Reacted After Ex-Pastor Ryan Bell All But Confirmed He’s an Atheist. Friendly Atheist, [online] Available at [Accessed 29 Dec 2014]

Merica, D., 2013. The money man behind atheism’s activism. Belief BLOG, [online] Available at < http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2013/03/23/the-money-man-behind-atheisms-activism/> [Accessed 31 Dec 2014]

Myers, P.Z., 2009. The Eagleton Delusion. Pharyngula, [online] Available at < http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2009/05/05/the-eagleton-delusion/> [Accessed 13 Feb 2015]

Myers, P.Z., 2011. Why are you an atheist? Pharyngula, [online] Available at [Accessed 30 June 2014]

Myers, P.Z., 2014a. Even an Increasingly Godless America Doesn’t Trust an Atheist to Run the Country. Time, [online] Available at [Accessed 14 Dec 2014]

Myers, P.Z., 2014b. Sunday Sacrilege: The Responsible Atheist. Pharyngula, [online] Available at [Accessed 12 Oct 2014]

Myers, P.Z., 2015. A classic mismatch, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 May 2015]

Openly Secular, n.d. About. Available at [Accessed 30 Sept 2014]

“Pharmaceutical lobby,” n.d. Available at [Accessed 15 June 2015]

Ravitz, J., 2014. Is the Internet killing religion? belief BLOG, [online] Available at [Accessed 30 Dec 2014]

Sandefur, T., 2011. Sam Harris, anti-reason. Freespace [online] Available at [Accessed 1 May 2015]

Schulzke, M., 2013. The Politics of New Atheism. Politics and Religion 6: 778–799.

“Skepticon,” n.d. Wikipedia, [online] Available at [Accessed 16 Dec 2014]

Smith, C. and Cimino, R., 2012. Atheisms Unbound: The Role of the New Media in the Formation of a Secularist Identity. Secularism and Nonreligion, 1, pp. 17-31. DOI: http:// dx.doi.org/ 10.5334/snr.ab.

Smith, J., 2011. Becoming an Atheist in America: Constructing Identity and Meaning from the Rejection of Theism. Sociology of Religion, 72(2), pp. 215– 237.

Stiefel Foundation, n.d. [online] Available at [Accessed 30 Sept 2014]

SSA, n.d.. [online] Available at [Accessed 30 Sept 2014]

Sullivan, A. 2014. Unbelievers in the Pulpit. The Daily Dish, [online] Available at < http://dish.andrewsullivan.com/2014/12/03/unbelievers-in-the-pulpit/> [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

Taira, T., 2012. New Atheism as Identity Politics. In: Guest, M. and Arweck, E., eds. Religion and Knowledge: Sociological Perspectives. Farnham, UK: Ashgate, pp. 31-43.

Thomson-DeVeaux, A., 2013. Rise of the “Nones:” America’s rapidly changing religious landscape. The American Prospect, [online] Available at [Accessed 30 Dec 2014]

Turner, B.S., 2007. Religious Authority and the New Media. Theory, Culture & Society, 24(2), pp. 117–134. DOI: 10.1177/0263276407075001

Warner, M., 2002. Publics and Counterpublics. Public Culture, 14 (1), pp. 49-90.

Watkins, D., 2014. Non-believing clergy. Lawyers, Guns & Money, [online] Available at [Accessed 3 Dec 2014]

Winegard, B and Winegard, B., 2011. The New Atheists, Political Narratives, and the Betrayal of the Enlightenment. The Real Delusion: Part 1. Dissent Voice, [online] Available at [Accessed 26 Jan 2015]

Winston, K., 2014. Atheist coalition wants you to know they are ‘Openly Secular’. The Washington Post, [online] Available at [Accessed 30 Sept 2014]

Winston, K., 2015. In a first, atheist activist addresses conservative conference. Religious News Service, [online] Available at [Accessed 1 March 2015]


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.